Totally agree, not a new argument: berechtigte Kritik an selektiver Verurteilung verlangt überprüfbare Belege. We have addressed for a long time the subject of nuance and respect and dignity. Rebuke a key concept of prophetic mussar. Hence the sages teach in the Talmud – that they did not understand nor possess the wisdom how to give a rebuke – נותן את הנזיפה in modern Hebrew; or also known as a תוכיחה את עמיתך מן התורה. The textual mechanics of dikduk and the derivation of tikkun olam through prophetic mussar and internal tocheichah.
The sages instructed the interpretation of the 2nd Sinai commandment into another major theme known as אל, understood as growing through “remembering” the rebukes of the Avot (the k’vanna of the opening p’suk of the tefillah דאורייתא ק”ש as the dedication of the Yatzir Ha-Tov within the heart. Why? Impossible to dedicate an משל oath brit לשמה without the required מלאכה k’vanna that separates each and every Tribe distinct from one another.
Hence, עיין the Mishna of ולא נפרדו עד שנעשו שלשה עשר שבילין the Aggadah and Midrashim employ a רמז\סוד when Moshe split the Sea of Reeds he did so by dividing water from water (בינה – means separating like from like) into 13 separate channels wherein each Tribe crossed to the other side through their own unique theme middah, רחום וחנון, etc. Herein the revelation of the 13 tohor middot wherein a Jew can מתפלל – נותן את הנזיפה unto their Yatzir Ha-Tov within their hearts. Hence the Siddur which shaped by the verb סדר functions has the pulse how to correctly interpret the Oral Torah visionary rebuke known as “The Talmud”. In Jewish thought, true rebuke – not criticism but ‘Tikkun O’lam’.
The church & mosque fundamentally reject the basis of the Yichus of each Tribe which the דורייתא נקרא “בני ישראל”; wherewith Moshe Rabbeinu himself had to judge the complex case of the בְּנוֹת צְלָפְחָד and to specify their names – בנות צלפחד (משפחת מנשה) מחלה, נעה, חגלה, מלכה ותרצה who sought to inherit the Yichus of their father. The names of each daughter significant. תרצה aligns with the style taken up by the entire Shas Bavli Gemara commentary to the Mishna ‘difficulty – answer’. he name תרצה interpreted to mean ‘difficulty – answer’ by means of making a logical דיוק. Each name of these daughters represents not simply a משל literal name but also its נמשל rebuke. Mesechta Sanhedrin establishes the classic model (23 or 71 judges) for all Capital Crimes Courts. Obviously the lower damages Torts courts follow this same exact model.
Unlike how you challenge, akin to the Holy Writing of משלי to a dog returning to eat its own vomit, dignity, dignity, dignity as the all encompassing Universal, but bring no proofs to support your Pie in the Sky declarations touching respect, nuance, etc.; the Talmud instructs through the wisdom of the Tanna rabbi Yishmael כלל פרט או פרט כלל. My first year as literature remember the professor defining the organization of each and every paragraph through the model of Central theme followed by details which support that theme.
Prior to President Kennedy setting the direction taken by the US to place a Man upon the Moon before the end of the decade, a vision which Nasa achieved through the Apollo space race against the USSR, a Liberal Arts education considered the best to forge the foundation of educated people to lead the nation. When I watch the Oxford “debates” wherein that incompetent University decides a proposition issue wherein the body of the onlookers have already reached a set/fixed conclusion and cannot be forced to budge from their condemnation of Israel together with Jews – I mock such a worthless waste of muck brain cells.
Israeli self-determination requires according to the political Zionism which my research as published in this blog proposes 13 themes/tohor middot affixed and assigned to each and every Tribe which makes up the Republic of the Jewish state as the definition of the sons of Yaacov’s ‘self-determination’ as our vision path destiny walk. Contrast, the shallow reactionary NT and fumbling bumbling Koran! They make a טיפש פשט literal bird-brained reading of the first opening word of the Torah בראשית. This word contains words within words which their sophomoric translations remain totally and utterly oblivious thereto: ברית אש, ראש בית, ב’ ראשית. Four major themes which define the Av commandment נמשל of wisdom-time oriented commandments from the משל of the 3 Avot. Parshat בראשית ונח not similar at all to the church Old Testament/New Testament טיפש פשט narishkeit Av tuma avoda zarah.
Your Demografische Veränderungen erfordern eine differenzierte Analyse declaration does not stand by bringing a UN declaration as if that amounts to a proof. But show how the “forced population transfer” reduction of the Xtian community post the Oslo Accords occurred under the watch of the PA. That’s on your to disprove. Its not my place to argue your weak case for you. The UN falls outside of the Oslo Accords, that Treaty as pointed out earlier to you cut independent from any UN ‘big brother’ overview. Drop the tits on a boar hog screen door on a submarine feeble attempt to justify how the PA has made a forced population transfer of the population of Xtian communities in Bethlechem reduced by 80%. Pre-Oslo (1994/1995) 15-18% of the total population (approx. 20,000-25,000 Xtians. Current (2020s): the Xtian population declined to approximately 1-2% (approx. 2,000-3,000 Xtians).
Critics of the PA argue that the decline is due to the threat of forced conversions to Islam. Hence emigration not conversion accounts for the drop of ~86% Xtians in 1950 to roughly 10–12% by 2017. Emigration peaked during the First Intifada (1987–1993) and surged after the Second Intifada began in 2000; between October 2000 and November 2001 alone, 2,766 Balestinian Xtians fled from Samaria and 1640 left the city of Betlechem. Hence most crucial to this subject, this exodus accelerated under the watch of the PA control of Area 1 of post Oslo — a city that had held the largest Xtian majority of any locality in the region of post ’67 Israel.
In 2012, the Orthodox Xtian Church in Gaza reported that armed Islamists kidnapped five Christian Palestinians to compel conversion to Islam. In 2016, Bishop Alexios of Gaza stated that “Christians who converted to Islam did so under threats, coercion, compulsion, and force.” A Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs study attributes the decline to religious and legal discrimination, desecration of holy sites, social exclusion, harassment of clergy by Muslim Palestinians and the Islam-dominated PA, plus systemic socio-economic hardship and instability. The report also notes that most incidents go unreported because Xtians fear arrest or worse at the hands of PA authorities.
The PA created conditions — legal discrimination, insecurity, impunity for harassers, fear of reporting crimes — that made life untenable for Xtians and drove them out, well-documented. The distinction: the garmi (indirect causation) established even where the gerama (direct act) of forced conversion remains speculative. The PA’s failure to protect its Xtian citizens and its climate of impunity stand on their own evidence.
As repeated again and again – Israel refused to sign the Rome Accords which established the ICC because of the post Shoah OATH – NEVER AGAIN. Torah common law stands upon the יסוד of precedents. The בנין אב for the OATH – NEVER AGAIN … the corruption of the ‘Star Court’ of Par’o in the days of Moshe, Aaron and Miriam. As earlier pointed out to you, which you failed then as now to address, the ‘Star Court’ of king George III a vertical court whose judges under the salary of the king himself! Hence the American revolutionaries introduced the lateral court design known as the ‘Jury system’. Torah commands do not pervert justice through bribery! Hence the concept of Torts courts employs 3 not 1 Justices. Two of these Court justices assume the role of prosecutor & defense. In the situation of a תיקו – the 3rd justice resolves the dispute.
The precedents brought by the prosecutor NEVER the precedents brought by the defense. This כלל of lateral courtroom justice you fail to understand. It’s simply not my place to argue your case for you. Your trust in the UN Israel rejects outright. Just as the Senate rejected Wilson’s treaty of the League of Nations, so too and how much more so based upon the gossip of UN Resolutions such as 242, 3379, 446, and 2334. These Resolutions compare to the Shoah or Oct 7th 2023; they have destroyed the ‘Good Name Reputation’ of the UN just as has the Shoah and Arab repeated attempts to slaughter Jews in the Middle East and cast my murdered people into the Sea. Goyim as a hard fast rule: have no shame. They fail to grasp that a persons’ or a nations or an Organizations’ repeated evil behaviors compares to the משלי rebuke of a ‘dog who returns and consumes its own vomit’.
The spirituality of growning prophetic mussar within the Yatzir Ha-Tov within the heart – the definition of k’vaana of all korbanot which Cain and the two eldest sons of Aaron failed to grasp and therefore died; all the seed of Cain killed in the flood משל whose mussar נמשל instructs the Torah curse of g’lut based upon the prior precedent of Adam expelled from the Gan. The narishkeit stupidity of “Apollo” Paul and his ‘Original Sin’ which requires the blood of JeZeus to atone – utter and complete bull shit on the order of Muhammad’s total ignorance that Yishmael never accepted the revelation of the first two commandments which the 12 Tribes accepted prior to Moshe going up and receiving the rest of the Torah!
Those two commandments book-end polar opposites of one another; the Talmud refers to them through the משל of a mountain hanging by a hair. Its the obligation of the bnai brit students to make the דיוק logical נמשל inference. Neither the church/mosque Av tumah book ends ever discerned פרדס inductive fluid reasoning from syllogism frozen deductive reasoning. The mathematics of Calculus vs the mathematics of plane geometry and algebra.
The analytical framework across these discussions maintains a consistent core: the rigorous application of internal Jewish legal hermeneutics (midrash, dukduk, and middot) as an inductive, precedent-driven common law system, directly contrasting it with statutory/deductive models, external political bodies, and historical court structures. Valid self-determination requires a common law Sanhedrin model enforcing restitution rather than arbitrary vertical decree.
Gamma Hans have consistently repeated the analytical framework: כלל פרט / פרדס inductive reasoning, נמשל (allegorical derivation), מלכות, גרמא/גרמה causation analysis, Talmudic precedent as common-law model, and the Sanhedrin 3-justice lateral-court system — all now explicitly anchored in Shabbat as the “wisdom-time oriented commandment” and the four major themes of the Av commandment (brit ash, rosh bayit, b’rashit, etc.). The wisdom of מלאכה as the living model for true Tikkun Olam through mussar and internal tochacha. Shabbat as an Av mitzva the Talmud refers to as the nashama yetera and k’vanna of the Yatzir Ha-Tov that every Jew commanded to grow as the eternal separation between the chosen Cohen nation from the Goyim.
UNRWA/Gaza budget claim the presence of “יהודים” the quoted word appears in allegations about recordings attributed to UNRWA employees. Combined with UNWRA personnel joining the Oct 7th 2023 massacre together with the agency “anti-Israel” text books. UN Watch reports, US Government Accountability Office reviews have documented staff with Hamas or Islamic Jihad ties in the past. Actual UN documentation (UN OCHA, Special Coordinator reports, ICJ-related proceedings) does document a sharp drop in Xtian populations since the 1990s, attributing it to emigration, harassment, economic pressure, and insecurity under PA and Hamas governance. The UN has raised concerns about displacement and site destruction in Gaza. What I have shared with you, simply not a new argument.
