As explained previously, the codification of the Mishna in 200, some say 210 CE roughly 75 years after the absolute disastrous defeat of Bar Kochba, where Rome renamed the conquered province Syria-Palestine. The Gemara sealed by Rav Ashi & Ravina in about 450 in Iraq; further editions made by the Sovariim scholars till about 600 CE! As such both the Mishna and Bavli Gemara more resemble Herzl’s “Jewish State”. No Yovel liberty for the 12 Tribe ever existed “historically”. Both king Shaul slaughtered the Kohonim of Nov as did king David ordered the death of Uriah – WITHOUT a Sanhedrin Capital Crimes trial. Hence neither king ever established Federal Sanhedrin common law legislative review of any and all statute law passed by Tribal authorities and/or the king of Jerusalem over a united 12 Tribe Republic.

Torah common law in essence interpretive rather than historical! When Herzl wrote his definitive work of political Zionism, Jews had endured almost 2000 years of g’lut! Hence the same equally applies to the authorship of both the Mishna and Bavli Gemara! From beginning to end – post Shoah Israeli National Independence – both the Bavli Talmud and Herzl’s ‘The Jewish State’ do NOT refer to history but rather encompass an interpretive vision of the Jewish state in the future.

As the T’NaCH engages in the history of kings, its foolish to assume that the T’NaCH primarily concerns historiography. T’NaCH prophets command mussar applicable to all generations of Bnai Brit Cohonim nationals ie the 12 Tribal yichus directly referenced in both the Torah and Book of Yehoshua. Confusing a secondary “detail” for the primary “k’vanna” amounts to confusion. Foreign invasions proved conclusively that prior to the people asking for a king in the Book of Shmuel, that the 12 tribes collectively as a whole ever enjoyed Yovel liberty based upon Moshe taking all Israel out of Egyptian slavery precedent.

History serves as contexts to make a depth analysis interpretation. The Mongols destroyed the Abbasid Caliphate in Iraq in 1258, the king of France and Pope ordered the public burning of all Talmudic manuscripts within France in 1242 under Louis IX. The interpretation of history: both the Muslims and Jews, so to speak ‘Circled their Wagons’. Prior to the disaster to both separate societies: Muslim wisdom and knowledge served as the light and model to the rest of the primitive & barbaric European countries – stuck in the Dark Ages.

After Rabbeinu Yonah realized that he had duplicated the exact same error as did the brothers dynastic dispute wherein the Romans occupied Jerusalem and appointed Herod ‘their’ king on that throne; Rabbeinu Yonah requested permission to burn Maimonidean works. Rabbinic g’lut Orthodoxy – unlike the P’rushim לשמה legalism – they thereafter embraced Greek schools of logic as kosher and therein blew out the Hanukkah lights. Despite assimilation to Greek culture, philosophy and logic – being a pig. Akin to Muhammad’s koran declared camels – clean! Furthermore, Rabbeinu Yonah profaned his public vow to visit the grave of Rambam.

Almost all later Talmudic commentaries written AFTER Rabbeinu Yonah invalidated his נידוי, [[[the most notable exceptions being the Rosh common law codification of the Talmud and such as Hasdai Crescas Or Hashem]]], the public burning of all Talmud manuscripts from France and the later expulsion of all Jews from France in 1306, virtually ceased all opposition to Jews learning and copying Greek philosophical schools of logic – a direct Torah negative commandment which interprets Egypt and Canaan as לאו דוקא.

The T’NaCH historical narratives serve as instruments of mussar, the oath brit sworn to and by the Avot defines t’shuva memory! Torah as a Constitutional document – NOT – a g’lut religious faith in some theologically constructed theology, such as Islam’s Tawhid Monotheism narishkeit. תורה לא בשמים היא the essential responsibility to rule the conquered land of Canaan through Sanhedrin common law legislative review of Tribal statute laws and some undefined Torah rhetoric “king” inclusive under the Torah Constitutional mandate which establishes משנה תורה courtroom authority has never yet occurred in any generation of the Jewish people to date.

Rav Saadia HaGaon (c. 882–942) perhaps one of the first Gaonim scholars actively embraced ancient Greek philosophy. The Arab conquest of much of Iberia traditionally began in 711, Saadia lived mainly in Egypt and Babylonia, within the Abbasid intellectual world. Greek works—including Aristotle, Plato, Euclid, Galen, and others—earlier re-discovered translated into Arabic, through the Abbasid translation movement, especially from the eighth through tenth centuries. His Rav Saadia HaGaon unlike Rambam, never a “straightforward” Aristotelian philosopher.

The conquest of much of Iberia began in 711, Saadia lived mainly in Egypt and Babylonia, within the Abbasid intellectual world. Greek works—including Aristotle, Plato, Euclid, Galen, and others—already translated into Arabic through the Abbasid translation movement, especially from the eighth through tenth centuries. His Book Kitāb al-Amānāt wa-l-Iʿtiqādāt, known in Hebrew as Sefer ha-Emunot ve-ha-Deʿot (The Book of Beliefs and Opinions), completed in the 930s, draws especially on Islamic kalām, particularly Muʿtazilite theology. Greek philosophy would later dominate virtually all “Golden Age” Spanish Reshonim thinkers such as Rambam and Ibn Eza, Isaac Israeli, Solomon ibn Gabirol, Judah Halevi.

These later Spanish Reshonim assimilated these ancient Greek ideas of deductive logic similar to how the Tzzeddukim adopted the ideas of making Jerusalem into a Greek city-state. Assimilation into ancient Greek cultures transformed the leaders of Spanish Jewry. The rediscovered Greek philosophical tradition became a major intellectual force in that euphemistic Jewish Golden Age medieval Spain.

The Talmud interprets the 2nd Sinai commandment, based upon other Torah commandment precedents, as do not assimilate and follow the customs manners or cultural traditions practiced by Goyim societies. This כלל defined through the פרט wherein the head of the Tribe of Shimon paraded past Moshe and Aaron with his Midianite wife; Ezra would demand that returning Jews from g’lut Bavil divorce their foreign wives.

The rediscovery of ancient Greek philosophy and logic reopened the Jewish “Civil War” known as Hanukkah some 1000 years earlier. Every Hanukkah, Jews remember in ועל הנסים Bencher: כשעמדה מלכות יון הרשעה על עמך ישראל להשכיחם תורתך. This phrase requires scholarship. Its vast scope includes the assimilated Tzeddukim who supported the rejection of the Oral Torah inductive logic system replaced by the Greek deductive logic formats, no different from the Shomronim who Ezra despised. The Syrian Greek empire sought to turn Jerusalem into a City-State.

Cyrus the Great paid from his own treasury for Ezra’s generations to build a “Temple” in Jerusalem. Ezra excluded the Assyrian Shomronim replacement populations; which the Mishna and Gemara of mesechta Baba Kama refers to all peoples’ who refer to themselves as the “real Israelites”, but who reject the revelation of the Oral Torah logic, later codified through פרדס inductive reasoning which defines all of Talmudic and Midrashic literature, under the general term Canaanites – a restatement of the Torah language “strangers”
דברים טה:כא – לגר אשר בשעריך תתננה ואכלה, או מכר לנכרי. The Talmud in this sense directly compares to the late 19th Century Russian socialist revolutionaries who had to conceal their radical political writings in an attempt to avoid Czar bureaucratic censors and/or secret police.

The Romans did not like this distinction wherein the Canaani had no social or legal rights to sue Israel for damages. Most superficial “historians” attribute the Hanukkah war to Antiochus IV and his supporters who favored Greek Hellenization of Judea. And ignore the long traditions started by Cyrus the Great as employing Banana Republic priests/Tzeddukim as the 2% fabulously wealthy caretakers who collected taxes from the impoverished conquered population of Judea. They “passover” the strategic necessity of building a Jewish temple as the means to collect taxes and ship resources of Judea back to Persia.

Some 1000 years later the reintroduction of Greek philosophy reopened the wounds of the Hanukkah civil war which pitted the P’rushim against the assimilated Tzeddukim who like the later church “denied” the existence of the Oral Torah פרדס logic kabbalah as later codified in the Talmud and Midrashim as the Horev revelation of 13 tohor middot Spirits.

During the Hasmonean period, almost immediately after declaring themselves as king, they broke their alliance with the P’rushim and cut an alliance with the Tzeddukim which initiated a civil war. The Hasmonean dynasty ruled for about 110 years before the Romans installed Herod. By some accounts a Century of their rule, Civil War fought between the P’rushim and Tzeddukim.

The Tzeddukim died as a class after the destruction of the 2nd Temple by the Romans. The church concealed the ancient Greek writings after Constantine converted to their faith and became emperor of Rome. Both the Western and Eastern church authorities viewed the Greek writings which dominated Roman polytheism culture as hostile. Renaissance scholars gained additional Greek manuscripts through Byzantine contacts, especially after, (with some minor exceptions), the fall of Constantinople in 1453. The concealment of those Greek ideas, together with the fall of Rome conquered by Germanic Tribes initiated the period known as the “Dark Ages”; akin to the three Century church imposed Ghetto Gulags upon the Jewish people. The rediscovery of the concealed Greek philosophies directly compares to the awe of Jews after Napoleon freed them from their Ghetto gulags.

The conquest of Spain by Arab armies, impacted the Western church something like a title wave hits the beaches. The ancient Greek texts no longer threatened the dominance of the church. Greek writings now read only secondary to the Bible itself! Xtian churchmen such as Augustine, Boethius, John Philoponus, Thomas Aquinas, and many Byzantine scholars now actively engaged in Greek philosophy. The expression “Dark Ages” recognizes the collapse of the Roman road system and collapse of international trade. The American and French revolutions introduced the distinction between serf vs. citizens. The British introduced the Industrial revolution which transferred the primary wealth producing capabilities of a nation from rural serf/lord communes to Cities – which in its own right caused a huge population transfer akin to Stalin’s wars against the kulaks of the Ukraine.

Saadia Gaon represents an early Jewish effort to employ rational argument in the restructured priority of “Jewish g’lut survival theology”. His scholarship obviously not identical to the Hellenistic crisis commemorated by Hanukkah. Instead it raised a related question, specifically how to address the Karaim rejection of the Oral Torah! How can g’lut Jews encounter an intellectually powerful external culture without surrendering Torah as the ultimate source of our Torah brit identity of Constitutional authority which mandates lateral Sanhedrin common law courts to rule the 12 Tribal Republic through legislative review over all Tribal and King statute laws?

Saadia’s sh’itta/methodology, compares to the Xtian word “converted”. He made “theology” the handmaiden of Torah common law – since no Sanhedrin courts can exist in g’lut! He employed סברה\reasoning/rationale as his היגיון logic. שכל\sechel – discernment skills which require the wisdom to separate like from like. For example wisdom-time oriented commandments which require k’vanna from תולדות/secondary commandments – both positive and negative – which do not require k’vanna but rather serve as precedents to employ sechel to interpret Oral Torah middot spirits as the dedication of halachic actions raised to דאורייתא מצוות.

His Kitāb al-Amānāt wa-l-Iʿtiqādāt employed Greek philosophy as a tool of his apologetics employed against the Karaim who rejected the Oral Torah as did the Shomronim and Pauline Church – all of which placed in the category of מלשינים. He clearly prioritized פרדס inductive logic over foreign deductive logic. The Rambam just the opposite, his code worthless to understand how the Gemara employs vastly different halachic precedent rulings as the chief tool to re-interpret the k’vanna of the language of the Mishna based upon a halachic fixed “witness” perspective; akin to the 3 views of a blue print.

Saadia, without Sanhedrin courts leaned upon Greek logic to support Jewish g’lut beliefs in “tradition”. Tradition which stands upon the kabbalah foundations of פרדס & the rabbinic middot “traditions” taught by Hillel, Akiva, Yishmael and HaGallilee. Sadducees rejected the Oral Law and the Resurrection of the Dead (concepts heavily tied to the emerging Rabbinic/Messianic theology). The dominant medieval Karaite position seems to have been closer to belief in a future resurrection, clearly influenced by Xtian and Muslim theologies. A study of Karaite theology notes that Karaites could affirm roughly twelve and a half of Maimonides’ thirteen principles, with the major exception being the authority of the Oral Law; akin to Rav Shach description of Chabad as “the closest religion to Judaism”.

The Xtian Bible affirms Daniel as a prophet. The Hebrew T’NaCH and Talmud mesechta Megillah openly states Daniel, not a prophet. Confusing a mystic with a prophet compares to prioritizing Greek deductive logic over Hebrew inductive logic – as did the Rambam. The concept of Moshiach applicable to all Jews in all generations who live in the oath brit land; based upon Moshe & Yehoshua prioritization of establishment of the Small Sanhedrin Capital Crimes Courts in the 6 Cities of Refuge and Brit melah which remembers the Avot alone (Yom Kippur t’shuva) as the fathers of the Cohen national Republic of 12 Tribes. Herein defines the mitzva of Moshiach from the Torah and also the resurrection of the dead. The latter linked directly to the first Torah commandment “be fruitful and multiply” as it applies to childless Avram who cut the brit between the pieces on this specific “future” condition being met by his O’lam Ha’Bah Cohen seed.

While the Hellenized Jews of the Second Temple period (like Josephus or Philo) used Greek philosophy to explain Judaism to the Gentiles (who specifically downplay the particularism of Torah common law courts as the only Constitutionally mandated basis of government rule of law), Saadia employed Greek philosophy to wall off Judaism from the Karaites. He obviously rejected the Tzeddukim attempt to make Jerusalem a Greek polis; the Babylonian Talmud served as the model for the future Jewish rule of Canaan through righteous judicial justice; as such only the T’NaCH/Talmud\Siddur sealed masoret exists as the valid interpretation of the Sinai constitution.

G’lut a Torah 2nd commandment curse. G’lut Jews by definition could not obey the Torah לשמה anymore than g’lut Israelites enslaved under Par’o and his corrupt vertical “Star Courts”! G’lut Jewry limited to Shi’ur Koma (the legal arguments) and the Psak (rulings). The Karaites, living in the same Islamic world, were adopting the “text-only” fundamentalism which defines both Classic Xtianity and Islam which Israelis like myself refer to as טיפש פשט.

The Rambam too rejected the Aristotelian doctrine of an eternal universe and defended creation in time. His טיפש פשט failed to grasp that the בראשית creation story/משל introduces the major Torah theme נמשל of wisdom-time oriented commandments! His code, interpreted through his bi-polar book of commandments fails to grasp the Av basis of Common law courts as wisdom-time oriented commandments based upon the foundational precedent of the Creation story which introduces the “thesis statement” of Torah Constitutional common law.

The error of reading the Torah as a history book as absurd as a Hercules man\God wherein Zeus rapes a married woman! Or the gospel narishkeit which declares that JeZeus fulfilled the words of the prophets! Mussar defines Torah prophesy just as the Jewish people has yet to establish a Torah Constitutional Republic of 12 Tribes – Yovel learns from remembering the oath sworn to the Avot “melah” and Pesach as remembered/t’shuva in the דאורייתא תפילה ק”ש. The 7th Middle Blessing of the Shemon Esrei remembers the redemption from slavery as רב חדס discernment – expressed in Talmudic Aramaic as מאי נפקא מינא?

Classic Diaspora (Galut) scholarship – inherently defensive or “assimilated,” whereas post-Shoah Israeli scholarship offers a different paradigm; a recognized historiographical debate, often associated with the “Canaanite” movement or the critique of the “Diaspora Negation” (Shlilat HaGalut) in early Zionism. Galut religious Judaism, the goal of statute halacha rotated around the central axis of preservation and boundary maintenance. The religious statute law became simplified & stable to assist g’lut Jewry to survive hostile assimilations; akin to a hostile corporate take-over of competition – environment. This created a “defensive” religious belief systems, which attempted to clearly define what Jewish theologians promoted as kosher belief in a Monotheistic God.

Post-1948 Israeli scholarship (e.g., the work of scholars like Yehezkel Kaufmann or later Menachem Elon, often prioritized the restoration of Jewish Constitutional common law as a national-constitutional system.), rather than religious ritual slavery obedience. The focus shifts from “how do we survive?” to “how do we govern?” The Herzl Jewish State nationalist model more resembles the NaCH mussar common law/\Talmudic-Midrashim common law which employs Gemara halachot as בניני אבות to interpret the language of the Mishna based upon a fixed perspective akin to how witnesses to the New Moon views-points differ from one another.

The style between the two sets of realities – radically changes. T’NaCH/Aggada-Talmudic halacha common law Court rulings, case-based: argumentative which weighs the precedents brought by the prosecutor with the counter precedents brought by the defense. This decentralized (((Vaguely like English Common Law but more like the post Star Courts American introduction of the lateral jury system. No English court has the authority to challenge a law passed by Parliament because Parliamentary statute laws define the British Constitution.))). The ghetto Shulchan Aruch halachic code permanently manifested the Rambam’s statutory and centralized (akin to Roman/Napoleonic Code). Israeli thought resembles to the original Reform post ghetto condemnation of Judaism as archaic laws. Ruling the land with righteous judicial legislative review, absolutely as a must, requires a revival the פרדס prophetic mussar vision – dialectical energy expressed through both the sealed T’NaCH & Talmud, to address modern statecraft. Whereas Galut Orthodoxy erroneously prioritizes the certainty of these religious statute-law Codes, akin to how the Wilderness Generation of Moshe cowardly refused to invade Canaan due to their faithless fear of giants in the land!

The trajectories of German philosophers goes from the realities of an Agricultural based economic system to an Industrial based economic system. Marx’s urban proletariat theory clearly contrasted by Bakunin’s Anarchist Mir peasant agricultural visions of socialism. Just as Mao’s theories of socialism likewise focused upon peasant realities which defined Chinese culture in the 20th Century. Nietzsche/Schopenhauer influenced the aesthetic and elitist aspects of Fascism (the Will to Power, the Übermensch). Bakunin, his social anarchism, inherently anti-statist and anti-nationalist. The evolution of the SRs to a federalist multiple state, later USSR Republic reality – structurally opposite to the Totalitarian State of Nazism. Herein an attempt to understand the reasons for Hitlers’ absolute hatred of ‘inferior race’ Slavic communism. The failure of liberal/bourgeois rationalism (Kant) led to both the irrationalism of Fascism and the agrarian populism of the SRs, despite the fact that these two branches of philosophy diverged violently.

Post Shoah Israelis view the Yad Chazaka as a revolutionary coping mechanism. It abandoned the vision of future O’lam Habah “Sanhedrin courts”, which stand upon the foundation of Yovel liberty for all 12 Tribes restored; its “replacement theology” created a religious “Civil Code” for g’lut Jewry. This “modern” Enlightenment-adjacent – made religious statute law far more accessible to the common man; it sacrificed akin to JeZeus on the cross, the פרדס middot of Sanhedrin common law as a vision applicable — when Jews slaughter the Romans and restore the Torah Constitutional Republic\Moshiach.

The 19th Century Reform leadership of Geiger or Holdheim viewed these static codes as utterly archaic dead remnants of ghetto g’lut. They openly called Berlin as their “New Jerusalem”! G’lut Reform Judaism, like Karaite rejects Oral Torah common law.

National leaders go to war when a nation or group of allied nations threaten their strategic interests. Making a string of “mathematical propositions” which fails to address the logic of the leadership directive of a Head of State/government throughout history fails to communicate any relevant information or analysis. For example the 1956 Suez War, where Britain, France, and 8 year old Israel made War upon Egypt.

The US response which threatened the stability of the fragile British pound forced both the British and French governments to stop their unilateral imperialism to seize the Suez Canal in order to dominate the balance of power in the region. Israel too forced to return the captured Sinai, which set the stage for the June 1967 War – eleven years later messiah Nasser promised to throw the Jews of Israel into the Sea! Quoting UN Charter as if they qualify as Xtian biblical verses amounts to tits on a boar hog.

The compare & contrast between the ’56 War to the ’67 War serves as concrete evidence that National leaders prioritize their nations’ national strategic interests far above and beyond the theology of UN religion. The 30 Years War pitted Protestantism of Luther and Calvinism against Rome. The slaughter of that War – unmatched till WWI! Quoting chapter and verse of the UN Charter as if you got religion simply shows your belief system that the UN serves as your God no different than JeZeus the God of both the Protestant and Catholic churches; Allah the God of Arabs & converted Muslims and the Crusades these two Gods fought one another. The barbaric JeZeus God thought Oh how quaint! Lets slaughter the Christ Killers in Germany … since we travel to conquer the holy lands.

The post WWII new God worshipped by secular nations today – the UN, simply replaces the earlier Gods worshipped by both Xtian and Arab/conquered Muslims like those two sets of Universal Gods repeatedly “war” against the local tribal god which the 12 tribes of Israel “alone” accepted at Sinai/\Horev. Replacement theology sucks eggs because it duplicates the Sin of the Golden Calf! Not the shallow reactionary and utterly simplistic טיפש פשט literalism that ערב רב – assimilated and/or intermarried Israelites bowed down to a literal golden calf. Rather that word-puke Name translations of nouns ((to quote you: “mathematically equals)) the רוח הקודש living Spirit revealed @ Sinai through the 1st Commandment and later @ Horev through the 13 Oral Torah middot “Spirits”. Noun words of this or that God(s) ≠ the revelation of the living Spirit revealed in the First Sinai commandment and again through the revelation of the Oral Torah 13 Spirit middot Spirits revealed at Horev post Golden Calf av tumah avoda zara where the ערב רב literally sought to substitute the name אלהים no different than you substitute the scriptures of the UN Charter for both the dead Gods JeZeus NT and Nakba Allah Koran!

1. Britain and France made war to dominate the Middle East as their own back yard as “Great Powers”. The response of the US President slapped both countries down as secondary States NOT comparable to the Cold War “super powers”. David Ben Gurion joined the British/French War to weaken Nasser’s Egypt – the primary threat to the continued existence of the Jewish state; whereas Jordan’s British lead and trained armies dominated the Arab world in the ’48 War, by the ’56 War the Nasser “revolution” had replaced the king of Jordan and the shining STAR wherein Arabs placed their Nazi hopes & dreams to exterminate the Jews across the Middle East; to achieve where Hitler and Chamberlain failed! President Eisenhower slapped down these secondary powers through the threat of imposing economic sanctions like brain-dead puppet of the VP “Dick”, imposed upon Saddam after 9/11 2001 and President Trump uprooted the equally Obozo the Clown treaty with the Mullahs and restored economic sanctions upon the Mullahs of Persia.

2. The worship of the UN Charter as a moral compass in international relations – compares to young children who go to bed hugging their Teddy Bear to protect and save them from the Buggy-man who often hides under the bed or inside bedroom closets! Both the League and the UN lack enforcement power; they do not possess the ability to police and investigate crimes ie detective work. The UN attempt to evade this fundamental flaw through Chapter VII “police actions” fundamentally dependent upon Great Power consent to participate as President Truman did in the Korean “police actions”. Congress post the Vietnam defeat passed the War Powers Act. And under the leadership of President Trump, Washington has slapped down the UN much like as did Ike London and Paris in 1956.

Nation States often treat the UN as their convenient whore. They ignore or manipulate its Resolutions and there’s not a damn thing the UN can do about it. Israel publicly tore up UN Resolution 3379 after its passage in that whore baiting gossip society. The UN no more Divine than JeZeus or Allah word-Names – Golden Calves. The Gulf War, Kosovo, Syria, Libya the major powers manipulated the UN like a boy arouses a virgin by stimulating her breast to convince her to open her legs. The UN has no police detective authority to enforce decrees made by the Security Council permanent 5!

Dark and Middle Ages replacement theology employed to justify antisemitism and colonialism now commonly expressed through the UN whore of New York and Geneva. Quoting the UN Charter like as did the Xtian and Arab/conquered Muslim converts to Islam do their sophomoric bible and koran corruptions of faith as false as the present day UN whose voting blocks and P5 worship Power as their God rather than the righteous pursuit of justice. Justice requires lateral common law courts to make fair restitution of damages inflicted by the powerful upon the weak. Both the religions of JeZeus and Naka Allah dead Gods. Upon this cracked and corrupt foundation stands the UN replacement theology God!

The Peace of Westphalia (1648) established the principle of state sovereignty, which is the foundation of modern international relations. It compares to the Peace achieved through the Post Napoleon Era which dominated European international relations till the rise of Communisms – the response to the Industrial Revolution which began in England just prior to the outbreak of the French Revolution which swept into power Napoleon. Bottom line: international relations – driven by power and interests, not by moral or theological propaganda frameworks; theological reductionism and literalist interpretations based upon sophomoric gossip translations from language to language compares to whispering an abstract idea in the ear of one person and that person in turn whispers what he heard into the ear of another. A chain whisper – by the end the message heard so completely different from the original – an utter joke.

Peace of Westphalia (1648) established Cuius regio, eius religio (whose realm, his religion). It didn’t solve theology; it bypassed it by prioritizing state sovereignty. It acknowledged that you cannot have peace if you are fighting over “God.” The Congress of Vienna (1815)\\Concert of Europe – maintained peace for a century not through moral preaching, but through a balance of power. When that balance broke (WWI), the moralistic Wilson’s “League of Nations” failed because it lacked the teeth of the Concert. The UN attempts to be a “moral court” without the “balance of power” backing it. It tries to legislate morality (like the Goldstone Report or various human rights councils) without having the power to enforce restitution.

The UN Charter serves merely as the “Teddy Bear” of nations whose fantasy of Superman or Spiderman etc defeats the foundation of Thucydides: “The strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must.” The “theology” of the UN, indeed just another version of the “Golden Calf”—a shiny, dead object that nations worship when convenient, and trample when the wheel turns and they rule with power. The Melian Dialogue (416 BC) – the only “law” that has held true for 2,400 years — “The strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must.”

We agree that Torah common law pre-dates British common law by thousands of years! Just as American common law courtrooms. The difference between British common law courtrooms and States common law courts … Parliamentary statute law defines the Constitution of Britain. Whereas the US has a Written Constitution which functions as a codified Basic Law of the US. Torah common law courts more resemble the much later US model rather than the Walpole version of British Constitutional law and courts.

Bunk on the UN fraud of block voting and great power imperialism. Both invalidate the creation of the UN to serve as a forum for diplomacy. The notion that the UN a World government which determines international law a total joke/fraud.

Israelis never throughout our long history as a people have never stated nor even implied we possess a monopoly on truth as have the jack ass Xtian church and Muslim mosque. We say that Jewish self determination expressed through the mandate of Torah common law Sanhedrin courts who maintain Yovel freedom for the 12 Tribes of Israel within the borders of conquered Canaan defines the Torah “Constitutional Mandate” which establishes lateral Federal and Levi Sanhedrin courts from Jerusalem to the 6 or more Cities of Refuge.

Torah mandated Sanhedrin Courts serve as the Capital Crimes Federal Courts whereas lower courts of Torts – 3 man courts jurisdiction – apply equally to Tribes of Israel and Jews in g’lut. Have repeated over and again that Torah commands mussar not history. Your attempts to demand history rather than mussar reflect a foreign monopoly of box rigid thinking. Goyim have their own legal systems. More power to them. Israel has yet to achieve the vision of self determination which stands upon the two legs of Yovel and brit melah as the prophet Yehoshua originally established prior to establishment of the 3 Cities of Refuges small Sanhedrin courts on the other side of the Jordan river as recorded in the first NaCH Book of prophetic mussar.

1. Torah law and British common law should not be equated because they arise from different legal traditions.
2. Israel’s non-membership in the Rome Statute by the explicit terms of the Oslo Accords eliminate ICC jurisdiction concerning the PA. Hamas who never agreed to the Oslo Accords and flat out rejects Oslo the ICC cannot declare Hamas as part of the PA since Hamas won the general elections in Gaza and violently expelled the PA from Gaza. Palestine ceased to exist as a UN protectorate the instant that Ben Gurion declared Independence and named the new nation Israel. No different than the US independence on July 4th 1776 from England.
   
   France’s permanent Security Council seat does not depend on Israeli recognition; it derives from the UN Charter. This does not change the cold fact that France behaved like a dog and surrendered to the Nazis virtually immediately. Attempts by the post Shoah ICC try to invalidate the disgrace of Shoah guilt by declaring that Goyim have legal jurisdiction to try Israelis. This invalidates the post Shoah oath – NEVER AGAIN.
3. The UN obviously fallible based upon the stated flaw fundamental realities of block voting and great power arrogance.
4. Torah commands mussar not history. Demands of Universal God A or Universal God B a long standing Goyim attempt to impose their monopoly upon peoples and nations. Torah truth – Goyim do not know how the Torah defines the 8 middah of the Oral Torah; the “path of truth” – righteous justice which makes fair restitution of damanges inflicted by Jews upon other Jews within the jurisdiction of the 12 tribe Republic. Goyim truth simply not the path taken by Torah self determination/Zionism any more than Par’o vertical courts in the days of Moshe and Aaron.

Israeli self determination to achieve Yovel liberty and restore the 12 Tribal Republic has nothing to do with the UN. Attempts by foreign states to dictate terms to Jewish self determination utter hog wash. Especially treif UN voting blocks and European & Russian fraud great powers attempts to dominate the balance of power held between the community of nations of the Middle East and North Africa. When Russia converts Istanbul back to Constantinople by UN decree only then can the UN likewise demand that Jews have no rights to achieve our destiny of Yovel liberty for the restored 12 Tribes of Israel.

French imperialism post WWI an abomination on par with British imperialism in China and across the Planet Earth. The British guilty of establishing Concentration Camps in the Boar War! Mussar rather than history not a theological box thinking static deduction. Mussar defines T’NaCH prophesy which both the Goyim Universal God religions have always invalidated. Hence what’s good for the goose good for the gander.

Yovel has nothing to do with religious beliefs any more than Herzl’s “Jewish State” a religious text! Any more than Vichy alliance with Hitler’s Nazis makes France a saint. Attempts to declare Poop Pius XII a saint only prove the despicable cowardice of European barbarians. Does the SC UN veto serves as proof – that the UN as a whole treif? No. But to date seeing the USSR boycotted the Korean Chapter VII SC vote, a error never again repeated, the confusion mad/made by the ICJ to expand Chapter VI Resolutions as on par with Chapter VII reflects how bureaucracies continually grow into Big Brother Governments.

Proof that Israel not alone in mocking “binding Charter obligations”? Name a single country expelled from the UN member status for ignoring these pie in the sky declarations of the post WWII past. SC Chapter VI decisions like 242 – 2334 all treif. Even post Obozo the Clown … 45 & 47th Presidents have invalidate the trash of the Obozo shoe shine boy in the White House, and replaced “its” incompetence with the Abraham Accords!

Repeated attempts to insist that mussar represents a theological rather than prophetic Torah definition of how prophets serve as the police enforcement arm of Sanhedrin courts – over and again attempt to impose a foreign perversion of T’NaCH as a religion based upon theology rather than the vision of Sanhedrin courtroom justice that remains the ideal of the revelation of the Torah at Sinai which only the 12 Tribes accepted. Attempts to pigeon hole “restoration of the twelve tribe Republic” as religious-nationalism proves that Goyim can’t think out of their boxed in static logic patterns. Oral Torah common law stands upon פרדס inductive logic not Greek syllogism deductive logic.

The Jewish state prioritizes brit-alliances and private diplomacy conducted with allies; over the gossip society of the UN which promotes block voting of foreign states interference in the internal affairs of other nations. The post Oct 7th 2023 massacre of Israelis on the last day of a Jewish Chag wherein the UN and ICC slander Israel as guilty of war crimes proves that the UN gossip society an utter abomination. Israel thumbs our noses at the UN and dares that incompetent gossip society to expel the Jewish State from the UN. To quote Eastwood: “Go ahead make my day – PUNK”.

The Torah concept of Yovel separates slavery to Goyim courts like the Par’o Torah example. Liberty for Israelites – to establish Courts of righteous justice which make fair restitution of damages: inflicted by Jews upon other Jews — the tiqqun of hatred without cause. The UN chatter box gossip Women’s Quilting & Terrorist Society prioritizes an eternal UNWRA Balestinian refugee status and right of return; rather than ever condemn the failure of all Arab countries Vichy Nazi\Muff Mufti duplication of Nazism; their refusal to repatriate their dhimmi refugee populations. Like the post Shoah disgrace of Spain who invites Jews back to that despicable European land. Israeli right of return, in fact awarded citizenship to the almost 1 million Jewish refugees violently expelled from Arab countries after the Nakab defeat of Allah and 5 Arab Armies and British/French attempts to re-establish a great power mandate over the Middle East.

Bottom line: Jewish self-determination, understood through Torah, Yovel, Sanhedrin justice, and restoration of the twelve-tribe polity, simply not dependent on UN approval. UN attempts to subordinated Jewish self determination to politically compromised international institutions reflects the revisionist history which denies that Israel won its TWO Independence Wars of ’48 & ’67. To the victors go the spoils; also known as Israeli ‘Manifest Destiny’ – from the river to the Sea’ the Republic of 12 Tribes shall rule the land through righteous justice-Yovel.

This premise requires proof: [Daraus folgt jedoch nicht automatisch, dass diese Normen heute die positive Rechtsordnung zwischen souveränen Staaten bilden.] Dhimmi Arab refugees not a State. Never has ever existed an Arab Balestinian state. [Art. 1 Abs. 2 nennt ausdrücklich die Selbstbestimmung der Völker.] All Arab wars against Israel center upon Arab rejection of Article 1(2) – yet the UN only condemns Israel?! What’s good for the goose Good for the Gander. Now that Syria in a state of anarchy, Israel needs to export all dhimmi ’67 Arab refugee populations to Syria, seeing that the Romans originally coined Syrian-Palestine!

Palestine ceased to exist in 1948. UN attempts to declare it remains as false as Arafat’s PLO charter of 1964; which only declares ’48 Israel as “occupied territory”. To say the comparison of Israeli Independence does not stand upon the similar precedent of American Independence – as to simplistic … easier to be a critic than a playwright dramatist than a post Shoah Jew. Jordan “acquired” the West Bank through force and Egypt acquired Gaza through force. Prussia acquired through force split between Poland and Russia today. These proof emphatically reject British-Frogs UN 242 “prohibition against acquiring territory by force”. Post 6 Day War UN gossip – 242 – falls flat on its face when confronted by the Khartoum Arab League: No peace with Israel; No recognition of Israel; No negotiations with Israel. The Women’s Quilting and Terrorist Society – Stitch N’ Bitch – their Resolutions simply gusts of 3379 farts in the wind.

Prophetic mussar does not stand upon history anymore that Avram who had no children but who cut a Oath Alliance to father – in the future – the chosen Cohen nation. This nation aint Xtianity or Islam religious theological bull shit. The language of גר לא תונה ולא תלחצנו, כי גרים הייתם בארץ מצרים, this p’suk refers to the Ger Toshav when the 12 Tribes rejoice in Liberty through Sanhedrin lateral common law courts. This has yet to actually “historically” to happen; any more than Herzl’s “The Jewish State” happened in his lifetime! Jews in the barbaric g’lut lands of Egypt (לאו דוקא) in the past 2000+ years of our g’lut among Europeans and Muslims never received judicial righteous justice from any Goy court of Law any more than when the ancient Israelites – the ‘Star-Courts’ of Par’o – sanctified “impressment” through illegal slavery on the High Seas/International Waters! Goyim have never accepted the Torah. Therefore Goyim cannot employ Torah translations to rebuke Israel to heel and roll over and play dead like a trained dog. Goyim simply not under the Law according to the Apostle Paul.

Dhimmi Arab dune coon-towel heads cannot even pronounce the P in the Roman word Palestine! Israel a tiny desert land about the size of New Jersey. Arab and Muslim countries include a land mass bigger than the United States. Goyim evil eye toward Israel reflects a gospel ‘Divide and Rule’ bull shit. Pakistan, Korea, Vietnam and Saddam’s attempt to nationalize Kuwait but ejected by the post 9\11 False flag attack wherein Cheney and his dog on a leash Bush (wag your tail) justified not only the disastrous invasions of Iraq but Afghanistan and who also imposed the Patriot Act upon the American people which negated to a very large degree the Bill of Rights. (Whom Bush famously declared: Don’t quote me the Constitution, its just a God damn piece of paper.) That child molester Bush (President Clinton – also know as the fuck between the Bush’s) promised “NO Nation Building”! Government rhetoric amounts to bull shit and so does UN morality.

Alabastersky greetings

As a Zionist, consider myself an atheist praise G-d. The theology bull shit of g’lut and Goyim does not interest me any more than Goyim attempting to inform Israelis of their own living history. Simply a crock of shit for Goyim in distant lands to read translations and pretend themselves experts on subjects as alien to them personally as living on the Planet Mars!

The German Gamma Hans continually demands “nuance”. Yet he quotes 17b of מגילה, divorced from its Mishna – hardly qualifies as “nuance”; but more like bobbing for apples in a barrel. The Gemara sugya – the first study of precedents to learn a depth analysis of הקורא את המגילה למפרע, לא יצא. קראהּ על פה, קראהּ תרגום, בכל לשון, לא יצא.

This first sugya a kabbalah sugya which prioritizes the 32 middot of inductive reasoning through precedent study of Rabbi Yossi Haglili – a third generation Tana, and one of the Sages of Yavneh following the Roman destruction of Herod Temple abomination. His reliance upon Chat AI only can translate words. Common law requires learning through precedents. Had he observed the Mishna which the first sugya of Gemara introduces inductive precedent comparisons to make a depth analysis of this specific Mishna – directly defines how to regard a translation to some other language.

Hence “Similarly problematic is the claim that Xtianity and Islam etc” A) they rely solely upon translations and B) Both openly deny the Oral Torah masoret! 7th Century CE measured from Ezra and the Men of the Great Assembly over a 1000 years distanct! By the Hebrew year of 2448 Jewish masoret places the event of the Sinai revelation. The Jewish count usually aligns the Ezra’s arrival about the Hebrew year of 3408. In the traditional Jewish timeline, this aligns with roughly 358 BCE (though secular history often places Artaxerxes I later, around 458 BCE, the traditional count shortens the Persian period). The timeline of 350–400 years after the First Temple’s destruction (traditionally dated to 3338 / 422 BCE in the Jewish calendar, though secular history says 586 BCE), consistent with the traditional view that the Second Temple stood for roughly 420 years. Hence approximately 900 to 1000 years.

The first word of the Torah בראשית contains ברית אש. What’s the Fire of the Brit? The 2nd Parsha of ספר בראשית — נח. Mesechta Sanhedrin learns the cause of the floods to sworn false oaths. ברית understood as “alliance”; the 12 Tribes forged a brit alliance to establish the 1st Republic. In similar vein the United States and the USSR — both Republics as were the ancient Greek Islands! To swear a Torah brit requires שם ומלכות based upon the precedent of blessings (a תולדות of oaths). His reliance upon Greek deductive logic rejected by the lights of Hanukkah.

Mishnah Megillah 2:1, because the opening sugya develops the Mishnah’s rule that reading the Megillah למפרע (“out of order”) does not fulfill the obligation, and that reading it orally, in translation, or in another language may likewise fail to fulfill it. The Mishnah – therefore part of the interpretive precedent, not merely background. His “shock” that the church abomination counterfeit detests the Oral Torah codified in the Talmud does not stand before the 1242 public burning of all Talmud hand-written manuscripts across France!

The wisdom of פרדס he does not have any education therein. The Bereshit–brit esh observation introduced aint a letter-based derash but rather a רמז – words within words! Like ראש בית ב’ ראשית which the Vulgate Latin and later vulgar Protestant bible translations totally ignore. Furthermore Aramaic very close to Hebrew. The Targum Onkelos if you don’t know the Hebrew word a person can count the Aramaic word for word 1:1 precision. The Greek and Latin language do not resemble Hebrew Aramaic any more than JeZeus has Yichus or the Goy Muhammad a prophet. Xtianity’s rejection of rabbinic culture and custom started way back with the letters of Paul which predate the Gospels themselves!

The cultures and customs of Greece and Rome share nothing with Hebrew culture and customs. Agape “love” does not mean the love contained within the language of קריא שמע, any more than the translation of covenant implies even remotely the oath alliance obligations of cutting a brit as a wisdom time-oriented Torah commandment.

What’s the major Torah theme that connects all NaCH Books? You have never even asked this basic fundamental question! Specifically how the NaCH flows from Yehoshua to Shoftim to Shmuel to M’lachim then to the major and minor prophets! Pathetic shallow reactionary reading does not amount to squat. How the Books of the Holy Writings starting with T’hillem etc refines and therein adjusts and interprets the k’vanna of NaCH prophets. This fundamental basis defines the relationship between the Mishna and the later Gemara.

The flow from Yehoshua through M’lachim to the Prophets – not merely a history of rising and falling kingdoms. The mussar theme instructs a continuous common law/legalism understood as the k’vanna of Yovel and brit melah זמן גרמא מצוות. This critical “nuance” both forgery NT and Koran “religions” pervert judicial common law courts unto theological religious belief systems.

Sanhedrin common law legalism rejects Greek logic formats due to their rigid deductive syllogism reasoning. Chag Hanukkah the P’rushim (The teachers of the Oral Torah masoret passed down to the rabbis, as expressed & codified in the Talmud; the nuance of the Talmud – that inductive logic, the nature of fluid dynamic reasoning defines the k’vanna of Oral Torah.), dedicated to only interpret the k’vanna of Torah זמן גרמא מצוות through the logic of Oral Torah reasoning!

Observance of Torah commandments לשמה defined as the pursuit of justice among our people. Justice has nothing to do with theological religious belief systems. The latter defines statute law codes established by Rambam and Karo in g’lut. The former’s statute law halachic code published after the massacre of German Jews by the crusaders and the latter’s statute law halachic code published prior to Western European Jewry forced into ghetto gulags for 3 Centuries.

According to the “path” the interpretation of אמת/eighth Oral Torah middah, זמן גרמא מצוות define the k’vanna of ברית אש\בראשית/ based upon the interpretation of the aggada of בראשית as introducing the Torah vision of אב זמן גרמא מצוות ותולדות קום ועשה ושב ולא תעשה מצוות. Where the toldot Torah commandments function as בניני אבות to “understand” (Discern like from like – such as t’ruma for the Cohonim to 10th dedicated to Levi and Chol dedicated to Israel.), the k’vanna of all זמן גרמא מצוות. Yovel a Torah commandment no g’lut Jew can keep. The Books of the NaCH & Holy Writings teach the theme that all the generations of the 1st Republic failed to keep the Yovel!

Hence the relationship of the Holy Writings to the NaCH prophets duplicated by the replica relationship between the Mishna and Gemara. The Book of דברים\משנה תורה introduces Torah as “common law/legislative review through the Sanhedrin court system”. Hence the Mishna – written some 75 years after the disaster of the Bar Kochba revolts where Rome renamed Judea unto Palestine-Syria directly compares to the k’vanna of Herzl’s Jewish State. Just as the latter does not bemoan the past so too the former; the Mishna and its later “holy writings” Gemara serves as the model vision when Israel rules Canaan and the nation lives through judicial justice wherein the Sanhedrin courts make fair restitution of damages inflicted by Jews upon Jews and terminates “hatred without cause” which the Talmud equates with Av tumah avoda zarah/Golden Calf.

T’shuva does not mean regret/repentance but rather the burden/obligation to remember the oaths sworn by the Avot wherein they cut the Torah brit of they alone as the Avot of the brit chosen people. The “shallow” reactionary bible reading made by sophomoric translations makes the gross error teaching bible as a linear history of moral decline which describes the plight of all mankind as “Original Sin of Adam”! A perversion only equaled by Goyim Legislatures validating that homosexuals have equal rights.

Made aliya back in ’91.  Called myself an atheist – praise HaShem, even while living in Oklahoma.  My family about 7 generations of lawyers & judges.  I personally despise the Yeshiva whose sh’itta of education made famous by Reshonim g’lut Jewry, employed to instruct Jewish children in Israel today.  Just as the mitzva of Shabbat requires making הבדלה which differentiates between מלאכה from עבודה so too and how much more so study and teaching of Torah requires making הבדלה which separates Common law from Statute law.  Alas, Yeshivah students which have crossed my path never taught that Shabbat means week, not the 7th Day of the week, as 7th day Adventists falsely teach!  

The Torah opens with מעשה בראשית – Yeshiva educated Jews never ask WHY?  Its simply not an issue of translating words from Hebrew\Aramaic to English.  The Rambam, his Yad-code basically translated the complex Hebrew Aramaic Talmud unto Hebrew – based upon the language of the Mishna.  The Steinsaltz talmud and Art Scroll translations follow the path set by that Reshon.  The impact upon the Torah world of the Rambam “translations” of Halacha into a simplified Hebrew most probably saved the language of Hebrew from going the way of Catholic Latin – a dead language. But his statute law code turned post Bar Kachba Mishnaic courtroom common law ideal for the future time when Jews conquer the Homeland and restore the pursuit of justice as our Sinai faith unto a static set of halachic religious laws – a belief system – in this sense: no different from Xtian and Islamic theologies.

The times for the Reshonim, cursed g’lut Jewry – exceptionally harsh.  The Romans scattered Jewry following the Bar Kochba revolt to the 4 winds of the empire.  Goyim barbarians in all cursed g’lut lands both Xtiandom and Islamic – like Spain, made forced conversions, forced population transfers akin to the ’48 Jews thrown out of all Arab countries!  The Reshonim scholars confronted harsh realities on the ground; Jewish settlements tiny & scattered and people during the period, where the Roman road system had collapsed, the Dark Ages, rarely traveled.  Spanish Jews – Rambam and Ibn Ezra, the latter fled for his life – from Spain, his son converted to Islam.  While the former too fled from the anarchy and chaos of the collapsing Islamic civilization unto Egypt; his brother drowned at sea!

Why did the Torah open with בראשית?  That Sefer has few Torah commandments: fruitful and multiply, brit melah, gid hanasheh, the טיפש פשט big 3!  But most commentators fail to grasp, (akin to the apostle Paul) that the Torah instructs prophetic mussar through repeated themes.  As most reform or conservative rabbis utterly numb. The Hebrew Siddur – an unrecognized Primary Source for Talmudic and Midrashic scholarship!  This sefer builds upon סמוכים, which requires a discerning eye.  The Siddur stands upon Sefer בראשית; it opens with תמיד מעשה בראשית – twice repeated in the first blessing for the שחרית קריא שמע.  That critical phrase answers the opening question of this paragraph.  The creation aggadah introduces the theme of Torah “wisdom” known as זמן גרמא מצוות. Shabbat as week distinguishes between לא תעשה מלאכה from תעשה מלאכה through k’vanna.

The bi-polar Rambam ספר המצוות in its טיפש פשט literalism, divides Torah commandments to positive and negative camps.  The B’hag by stark contrast, his introduction discerns between Av from toldot commandments; like both mesechta Shabbat and Baba Kama ask the question  התולדות הולכים אחרי אבות? Just as quality scholarship separates between Primary from Secondary sources – a Ph”D from a bachelor degree. The Sages distinguished between Torah from NaCH from Writings … Mishna from Gemara, so too and how much more so down stream generations of Yiddishkeit likewise required to respect this masoret of scholarship. The B’HaG recognized T’NaCH\Talmudic common law. The Rambam’s statute law effectively blew out the lights of Hanukka; wherein the P’rushim defeated the assimilated ערב רב Tzeddukim. Perhaps based upon the בנין אב of blowing the shofar; this mitzva of blowing the Shofar – a חכמה – the Rif made the chiddush that a person could blow the Shofar on shabbat before his Court!

The term מלאכה refers to Av Torah commandments – time-oriented commandments – which require k’vanna. Toldot commandments and halachot learned separately – as does the statute law code of the Rambam and the Shulkan Aruch – do not require k’vanna. For example: What constitutes as תפילה דאורייתא vs. תפילה דרבנן also ודוי דאורייתא vs ודוי דרבנן? The Rambam harshly criticized in his Introduction שרש ראשון the B’HaG who ruled תפילה דאורייתא! Yet in Rambam’s 5th positive commandment, he too ruled tefillah a mitzva from the Torah! B’HaG learned Hanukkah, a mitzva from the Torah which the Rambam likewise considered absurd. How did the last of the Gaonim scholars “confuse” rabbinic commandments? The Talmud refers to Hannuka מחובר and the Baali Tosafot refers to קריאת שמע likewise as מחובר. The Av Torah זמן גרמא מצוות – מחובר.

The Baali Tosafot refers to the mitzva of ק”ש as מחובר; meaning time-oriented commandments. The B’HaG refers to the lighting the lights of Hanukkah as a מצוה דאורייתא; meaning זמן גרמא מצוות. The statute codes by contrast err and interpret through a טיפש פשט “time” understood in the literal sense. חכמה defined as זמן גרמא מצוות – חמובר. Whereas תולדות מצוות לא צריך כוונה… זמן גרמא מצוות מחובר לחכמה מן התורה. Just as Shabbat means “week” and not a day in a week, so too and how much more so בראשית introduces the theme of זמן גרמא מצוות as Av tohor commandments and not the World created in 6 days טיפש פשט.

The זמן גרמא only a משל which requires making the logical דיוק נמשל. Not literally “time as in watch”, but Torah wisdom as the נמשל of the משל of זמן גרמא מצוות. Hence to both the B’HaG and the Baali Tosafot: where the Baali Tosafot refers to the mitzva of ק”ש as מחובר; meaning time-oriented commandments. The B’HaG refers to the lighting the lights of Hanukkah as a מצוה דאורייתא; meaning זמן גרמא מצוות. The statute codes by contrast err and interpret through a טיפש פשט “time”, understood in the sophomoric – literal sense. חכמה defined as זמן גרמא מצוות – חמובר. Whereas תולדות מצוות לא צריך כוונה… זמן גרמא מצוות מחובר לחכמה מן התורה. The Av בנין אב for all זמן גרמא מצוות … תמיד מעשה בראשית. Sefer בראשית opens with the Central Torah theme of Av tohor time-oriented commandments. Whereas the Books of שמות ויקרא ובמדבר instruct בניני אבות תולדות מצוות. As these secondary commandments – when attached by means of inductive פרדס inductive reason logic to other similar Case/Din rulings (both in the literature of the T’NaCH prophetic mussar and Talmud ritual halacha) this חכמה compares to the two sights of a rifle which permits the prophets to “shoot” their mussar to all generations of the Chosen Cohen People. Herein defines the warp/weft halachic-aggadic relationship which permits the generations of Israel to make aliya from g’lut toldot commandments to Av tohor זמן גרמא מצוות בארץ ישראל.

The זמן גרמא only a משל which requires making the logical דיוק נמשל. Not literally “time as in watch”, but Torah wisdom as the נמשל of the משל of all זמן גרמא מצוות. Hence the B’HaG and Baali Tosafot, specifically the Rabbeinu Tam most likely, מחובר…חכמה “joined/attached” to that חכמה מן התורה which requires k’vanna. Translating the term עדיף\מחובר misses the point all together. This term refers to the distinction between Av Torah commandments – which require k’vanna from toldot commandments which do not require k’vanna. Hence תפילה דאורייתא that’s ק”ש. The Siddur through סמוכים affixes ק”ש to Shemone Esrei דרבנן.

Brought this example as a proof that T’NaCH and Talmud BOTH command common law legalism which learn through judicial precedents. Translating simply misses the boat and qualifies as a לא לשמה Torah curse, based upon the בנין אב of the 1st Sinai commandment. G’lut Jews cannot keep the Yovel – impossible; no different from the slaves beaten by order of Par’o vertical courtrooms (Star Courts which justified impressment of American sailors seized by British warships on the High Seas). G’lut Yidden got religion through the statute halachic codifications.

Only in Israel can Jews sanctify צדק צדק תרדוף; prior to the Oct 7th 2023 Abomination War, Israelis confronted a judicial crisis! Can Israel achieve self-determination and affix the 12 Tribes to the re-conquered lands of Canaan and therein re-establish our Constitutional Republic wherein the Torah mandates only Federal Sanhedrin courts which possess the mandate to rules the Tribal “legislatures” and Knesset Central Government statute laws through משנה תורה-Legislative Review?

The Pauline “original sin” of Adam such a bull shit model. Why? Torah spins around the central axis of justice/injustice. The “fruits” of knowlege of Good and Evil, validates that both Adam Cain and the 10 generation thereafter all pursued “evil”. But the term “evil” does not mean “sin” as the NT counterfeit substitutes for evil. The Pauline model of “Original Sin” and “Salvation”, exposes a fundamental perversion of the Torah’s choice-and-consequence framework, leading to theological and moral failure define av tuma avoda zara expressed by the pervert religions of Xtianity and Islam – both guilty of substituting “Nakba” Gods as the saviors of Israel in Egypt.

Evil has its consequences. The jealous brothers of Yosef sold their “brother” into slavery! This evil cause the House of Yaacov to go into Egyptian g’lut! The exact same theme as Adam and Noach! The latter cursed the first born son of Ham! The 6 against 6 blessings vs curses sworn at Sh’Cem by the 12 Tribes of Israel obeys the blessing curse Torah which Moshe commanded Yehoshua to do – upon bringing the chosen Cohen people into the land of Canaan. Herein defines the k’vanna of the Order of the Rabbeinu Tam tefillen.

JeZeus saves from sin – simply – bull shit. This foreign imported Nicene Creed g’lut caused – av tuma import; simply stated, has no portion with the first two Sinai commandments. Evil called sin by the NT fraud – a perversion on par with Brit called covenant by both counterfeit religions! Shalom, based upon the shabbat 3 meals, stands upon trust. Peace a noun has no direct connection to the trust verb. Hence peace a fraudulent translation of shalom.

Every generation of Humanity experiences the fundamental הבדלה which separates Good from Evil; where ‘fear of heaven’ serves as the foundation of good and no ‘fear of heaven’ serves as the foundation of evil. Despite the NT fraud, “JeZeus saves from sin”, this foundation of the Torah, introduced in the opening פרקים of Sefer בראשית, defines the essence of “acceptance of the yoke of the kingdom of heaven” metaphor. Despite the revisionist av tuma avoda zarah theologies and their טיפש פשט which worships their own ‘world to come’ Pie in the Sky alien narishkeit belief systems. Any judge who hears a case before his court while holding strong beliefs pro or con, as corrupt as if he had accepted a bribe.

The Talmud publicly repudiates the JeZeus prayer which prays to ‘our Father in heaven’. The mitzva of tzitzit, (the 3rd פרק of the ק”ש תפילה דאורייתא), the aggada in ברכות commands the mussar that mitzvot sanctify only brit Israel now living בעולם הזה; Jews visiting their buried dead, halacha commands – tuck your tzitzit into your pockets. The tohor\\\…///tumah prototype mirror of the Tree of Knowledge of Good & Evil; the Torah נמשל for this Torah משל, akin to two branches of one tree. This archetype blue-print the counterfeit religions totally fail to grasp; tuma does not mean “SIN”.

The foreign paradigm of “Sin” perverts the Torah connection of g’lut to tumah. Both bible and koran ignore judicial injustice which fails to make fair restitution of damages as the תקון for hatred without cause, as the av tuma middot consequences of the Torah curse of g’lut. The KJT bible perverts tuma as “unclean”. The koran fails to grasp that camel a tumah animal on par with pigs. The birth of children does not make a woman “unclean”; simply because fruitful and multiply serves as the – so to speak – first born child of all wisdom\time-oriented commandments!

The tohor-tuma vision fits hand-in-glove with the blessing/curse opening Sinai commandments which all Israel (alone) accepted at Sinai; Moshe Rabbeinu in the closing Parsha of ויקרא and repeated – in further detail – in דברים; the Parsha publicly read prior to ר”ה – these two “Crowns” of oath brit לשמה מלכות responsibility. They define prophetic mussar ברית חדש understood by rabbi Yechuda as בכל לבבך\כם in the ק”ש תפילה דאורייתא, the opening paragraph – blessing and the 2nd paragraph – cursing. Whose 3rd פרק defines this mitzva as a time-oriented commandment “sworn oath/brit”. Such a Torah oath brit absolutely & most essentially entails מלכות לשמה. A king accepts responsibility for the actions of his nation.

Actions have consequences like ripples after a stone thrown into a pond. Post the Bar Kochba revolt Rome renamed Judea to Palestine-Syria, and cast the Jewish people back unto Egypt – a לאו דוקא metaphor for av tuma g’lut. Post Shoah, both church & mosque – destroyed their ‘good name’ reputations. Their bemoaning their own g’lut consequences with ‘true Xtians or Muslims blah bhah’ excuses, screams “we do not accept the consequences of our actions, made by the generations of our faith”; we have no God because our Gods proven utterly be dead. Where was JeZeus during the Shoah of European Jewry by Xtian monsters? (Europe a self proclaimed Xtian society since Constantine!) Where was Nakba Allah during post WWII repeated attempts to throw the Jews into the Sea – to complete the Nazi Shoah in the Middle East?

Both fraud faiths NT or Koran embrace inherited guilt rather than cause and effect consequences of knowledge of Good and Evil; rational consciousness of choice, despite the dogma of ‘Free Will’, shares no part with modern Nazism notions of racial DNA models. “The fathers have eaten sour grapes, and the children’s teeth are set on edge”, that prophet’s mussar explicitly rejected. Yehezkel instructs the נמשל that all generations must confront the Havdalah, Good/Evil -understanding: the consequences of ones’ actions either sanctifies a good name reputation or destroys and profanes a good name reputation. Declarations of faith in a theologically created abracadabra Tawhid Monotheistic Universal God do not and cannot change the consequences of unjust actions through condemnations of dead generations guilty identical crimes, committed by each and every generation their after!

A person can become tuma without “sin”, ba’al keri or metzora serve as witness. In the Book of מלכים metzora folk informed the king that the Assyrian Army had fled which immediately terminated the famine within the city, consequent to the siege. The Pauline Grace/Forgiveness dynamic has no portion in Torah faith just as brit melah and Torah common law has no portion with any church or mosque rule of law or “eirene” – granted by faith in a Hercules (Man\god) savior or some Muhammad who claim himself a prophet without wisdom how the Torah defines this key term. Prophets not mystics whose visions foresee future events. Prophets not witches whose magic speaks to the dead. The Book of Daniel not included in the NaCH prophets because even tohor mysticism such as expressed through Daniel and Zohar and Ari mysticism does not qualify as נבואה

Tzitzit do not learn from any worship of wood and stone grand Temples in Jerusalem! Tzitzit, this wisdom commandment learns from the כלל of Tents established by the Mishkan “revelation”; כלל: if a person dies under a tent – all within the tent become tumah. Covering the head with the tzitzit tallit “Amidah” interprets the k’vanna of tzitzit as mussar. The wisdom commandment of tzitzit elevates all mitzvot and halachot under this Mishkan like “tent” unto wisdom/time\oriented Torah Av commandments.

The NT “JeZeus” who “saves from sin” but allows ghetto gulags, Inquisition & shoah – simply a logical contradiction on par with the Nakba defeat of Allah whose peoples religiously affirm the Nazi Shoah as their ideal. The Calvinist dotrine of ‘predetermination’ & Lutheran ‘free will’ protestant faiths as corrupt and false as Pope Pius XII watching the Nazi SS herd the Jews of Rome to the death camps … followed up by the post war Rat-lines and pogroms! The NT’s “Original Sin” and “Salvation from Sin” model of faith – a fundamental perversion of the Torah’s “Choice and Consequence” model.

Xtianity suffers from an Av tuma: God on the brain syndrome. A disease that plagues the Muslim world as well. The Book of Shoftim instructs the bitter mussar that the 12 Tribes had yet to achieve the commandment of Yovel! The precise preconditions established by the talmid of Moshe Rabbeinu in the Book of Yehoshua. This post WWII fad, which breaks the disgraced Shoah church evil name, and attempts to switch to “Yeshua” as the identical name of JeZeus. However your Hercules son of Zeus – Harry Potter – has no Yichus – no tribal inheritance. Which the father alone determines – JeZeus has no connection to the mitzva of Yovel, nor brit melah – which remembers the Avot as the sole “fathers” of the chosen Cohen People.

Sucks being so reactionary blind that you cannot see the forest through the trees…so heavenly minded that you lose all the rational ability to discern a cheap counterfeit copy. The fundamental NT problem, your apostle Paul – told you that brit melah does not qualify as a Torah commandment for Goyim. To what does this stupidity compare? We Jews say your false messiah Man/god aint a Torah commandment of Moshiach because Goyim switch a Torah commandment with Greek theology just as the Koran does not grasp that prophets command mussar which define the k’vanna of all Torah time-oriented commandments.

Why? Because the “father” of JeZeus not a Man according to all the books of the four gospels! This makes the gospels into a myth Hercules Man/god who has absolutely no “Yichus” — tribal inheritance! A truly dumb ass ooops, fundamental insane error made by the gospels framers – Harry Potter counterfeit messiah. Based upon the critical בניני אבות – Yovel and brit melah – the basic fundamental requirements, required for any Yid in all generations of the descendants of the seed of the Avot – to sanctify the mitzva of Moshiach. A Yid who does not have a brit melah has no obligation to sanctify Torah commandments any more than a House without a foundation qualifies as something more than a temporary tent! G’lut Jews observe rabbinic commandments in order to remember should they merit to move to Israel, what it means to actually do mitzvot לשמה.

An uncircumcised Jew, clearly a בדיעבד status; for example the Book of Yehoshua opens with the descendants of the Wilderness generation getting a brit melah in the land. Just as its impossible to turn a pig’s ear into a silk purse so too and how much more so make a בדיעבד into a Torah לכתחילה. The Talmud compares it to a tuma Jew who tovel’s in a mikveh while holding a dead rat in his hand. The mitzva of Pesach not applicable to Goyim because they have no brit melah. Brit melah an Av wisdom time-oriented Torah commandment. Pesach functions as the בנין אב whereby Jews learn the k’vanna wisdom of the time-oriented commandment – Yovel – tribal freedom/liberty in the land of physically conquered Canaan, based upon the בנין אב of the tuma Wilderness generation contrasted by the generation of tohor Yehoshua who strove to sanctify the mitzva of Yovel in the land.

Young David referred to Goliath as an uncircumcised Philistine! G’lut statute law halacha not the same as the Mishnaic לכתחילה of Sanhedrin courtroom common law צדק צדק תרדוף. G’lut statute law halachic codifications function only as a coping mechanism to aid Jews survive some type of Jewish identity intact under the horrors of g’lut Par’o like oppressions – blood libels forced population transfers taxation without representation pogroms … shoah. Hence the statute law Roman Senate decrees duplicates the Constitution by British Parliamentary law; where the British courts have no authority to overturn Parliament decrees of law. Assimilated Jewish halachic law codes codify the religion of Judaism in g’lut. They do not shape nor determine Sanhedrin common law courtrooms לכתחילה after the liberty of the 12 tribal yichus and the time-oriented commandment brit melah which requires the k’vanna to remember that the brit sworn to the Avot — that only they would father the chosen Cohen people. The “t’shuva” made by HaShem on Yom Kippur wherein the vow to make Moshe the father of the Cohen people proves the k’vanna of brit melah! T’shuva as different from ‘Goyim repentance’, as Moshiach – a Torah commandment – as different from the Sinai לשמה – who commands the revelation of the Torah at Sinai.

A Jew who fled from the chaos of the collapsed USSR, many of them had no brit melah. For them to observe Pesach לכתחילה rather than בדיעבד – they had to first get a brit melah. The mother determines the Jewishness of the child. The tribal yichus of the child determined alone by the father. For example, a Cohen requires that his father – not his mother – be a Cohen. This example applies straight across the yichus of all 12 tribes – the father alone determines a person’s tribal Yichus. In the current Jewish secular Jewish state where the Knesset Parliament rules as a democratically elected central government – the Torah לכתחילה which requires tribal yovel and brit melah as determined by the prophet Yehoshua Jews have yet to achieve. A Greek culturally influenced democracy does not compare to a Jewish tribal republic; anymore than does משנה תורה-judicial legislative review-compare to British statute Parliamentary laws.

The Book of Ezra ruled that the mother determines the Jewishness of all born children after Ezra commanded all Jews returning Jews to divorce their shikza wives. The case of the daughters of Tzelofchad in במדבר teaches that the fathers determine the specific tribe of the Jewish child. For example: aggada states that the Avot kept all the mitzvot. If so, then Yishmael – having a brit melah would have qualified to keep pesach along with Yitzak! However, Sarah following the brit melah of Yitzak terminated all doubt. She commanded Avraham to cast out this bondwoman together with her son – that only Yitzak would inherit the brit. What בניני אבות does Sarah’s ruling stand upon? The rejection of first born Cain’s korban. Brit melah no more a barbeque to heaven than the two sons of Aaron’s offering qualified as a wisdom time-oriented commandment. Hence both this and that rejected. The wisdom of all time-oriented commandments – a matter of the heart.

Brit melah not a biological fact; Torah commands mussar not history. As a father can annul his young daughter’s vow, so too can a baal – the vow made by his wife. A Torah oath not even G-d can annul, any more than the two legs of a right triangle – each separately – longer than the hypotenuse. The בנין אב for the distinction between a Torah oath from a תולדות vow, the difference between making a blessing from saying a praise. Blessings תולדות of שבועות. Praying תהילים only a lower שבח/praise. בראשית – ברית אש. What’s the Fire of the Brit? Torah oaths. Hence Mesechta Sanhedrin links the floods which obliterated the generation of Noach – the consequences of sworn false oaths.

G’lut Judaism bemoans the Assyrian g’lut for the inability to ascertain tribal lineages! However, the Torah employed the Goral to determine tribal yichus affixed within the land of Canaan; Assyrian g’lut does not over-ride the employment of the Goral mitzva anymore than does the yichus of a man – living in the tribe of his wife – changes the borders of that tribe – as originally established by that Goral mitzva. A dispute over how to “interpret” the Goral mitzva, like any other halacha requires a Great Sanhedrin court ruling. For example: the Goral of Gad yichus affixed to the Golan inclusive of Damascus; or the Goral of Reuven yichus affixed to Gaza.

G’lut rabbinic opinions do not possess the authority to overrule opinions made by a sitting Sanhedrin court; 1000 year old opinions do not qualify as הלכה למעשה. A modern Goral which affixes the yichus of the examples of Reuven and Gad has never existed. It would require a Sanhedrin court to issue such a Goral. The Sanhedrin Courts system not dependent upon a Cohen HaGadol nor Urim veTummin. While the Cohen HaGadol serves as the primary בנין אב for the mitzva of Moshiach from the Torah, צדק צדק תרדוף mitzva affixed to the establishment of large and small Capital Crimes Sanhedrin courtrooms.

Moshe Rabbeinu did not take Israel out of the judicial oppression of Par’o and his vertical ‘Star Courts’ in order to copy the ways of the Goyim who worship their Gods by building Great Cathedrals or Temples. Yetro clearly instructed a powerful mussar, that Moshe himself alone could never judge the entire nation with צדק. That the tribes of Reuven & Gad sat outside the land of Canaan addressed a בדיעבד situation based upon the pre-conditions Moshe placed upon these tribes to serve as the tip of the spear to assure that the other tribes inherited the land of Canaan.

Post the disaster of the Bar Kochba Revolt and the Roman expulsion and name change over to Palestine-Syria, the publication of the Mishna in 210 CE could not refer to Sanhedrin courtroom rulings of the past because throughout the בית שני period the mitzva of Yovel דאורייתא never observed. Therefore despite a Great Sanhedrin court in Jerusalem the small Sanhedrin courts and Cities of Refuge never resumed throughout the בית שני. The Great Sanhedrin could no more try Herod than the Sanhedrin in the days of Napoleon could demand that France immediately surrender to England or Russia! Yovel liberty of the 12 tribes and Sanhedrin משנה תורה legislative review – both dependent upon Jews conquering the land of Canaan, like as occurred post the 1967 Six Day War.